data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a31aa/a31aac7c9283928b6b382e0067df18d434226321" alt=""
The usually hysterical Connolly plays it straight this time around, taking on the part of a disturbed Catholic priest--despite his real-life atheism. Incidentally, Connolly also played the title role in Fido, in case you didn't recognize him under all that makeup (and yes, he was also Howard Hesseman's replacement on Head of the Class.)
According to The Independent, the part of Father Joe was specifically written by Chris Carter with Connolly in mind. Check out the interview here.